The acting chief executive of the Chinese pet-subscription company argues that growth means little unless each delivery pays for itself, and he rebuilt MollyBox’s operations around that idea.

Subscriber numbers have proved a poor guide to the health of subscription businesses. Flowerplus, an early leader in China’s flower-subscription market, reached 8 million users in 2022; in September 2023 it temporarily suspended service, citing a shortage of funds, according to KDDI Research. In the United States, a McKinsey & Company survey found that more than a third of consumers who sign up for a subscription service cancel in less than three months.

MollyBox has taken a different path. The company launched its cat-supply subscription box in 2017, offering three-, six- and twelve-month plans at roughly RMB99 to RMB300 a month, and had about 320,000 users by 2020, according to KDDI Research. It now counts more than 300,000 active subscribers among more than three million paying customers, founder Damian Yi Ju said.

The person most responsible for how the business runs is Simon Zhou, who joined as supply chain director in December 2020 and has been acting chief executive since November 2022. His argument is simple to state and harder to carry out: a subscription company is judged on growth, but it survives on what each order contributes after the cost of delivering it.

“People look at subscribers and recurring revenue,” Zhou said. “But a box is a promise you have to keep again next month, and the month after. If keeping it costs more than the order brings in, growth only makes the problem bigger.”

The arithmetic of a box

Pet subscription is a demanding version of the model. Acquiring a subscriber is expensive, the value of an individual box has a natural ceiling, and customers choose the service for convenience and personalization rather than the lowest price. That leaves little room to raise revenue per order, Zhou said, and makes cost the main lever.

The bundle adds its own pressure. A box ships complete or not at all, so a shortage of one item can hold up the whole order, and shortfalls compound. “If a box has six items and each one is in stock 95 percent of the time, only about three boxes in four can ship complete,” Zhou said. “Item-level numbers can look fine while the customer’s experience is not.”

When Zhou took over the supply chain, planning was fragmented and fulfillment costs were high. He connected planning from demand forecasts through procurement and fulfillment and introduced digital tools for daily ordering and inventory management. The service rate rose from 67 percent to 90 percent during his tenure, according to company figures.

Cost per order

The largest change was in the cost of getting each box to a customer. MollyBox’s fulfillment-cost ratio fell from approximately 15 percent to between 7 and 8 percent after the company restructured its warehouse locations, closed redundant sub-warehouses and changed its packaging materials, according to the company.

For a subscription business, that difference flows directly into how quickly the cost of acquiring a customer is recovered. “Every point of fulfillment cost comes out of what an order contributes,” Zhou said. “In our category you can’t easily raise the price of a box by eight or nine percent. You can take that much out of the cost of delivering it.”

Fewer products, better boxes

Zhou also targeted the range itself. Each additional product needs a forecast, a purchase decision and a place in the warehouse, and in a curated box it is one more item that has to be available at the right moment. A procurement dashboard linking demand forecasts with the product matrix, combined with multi-sourcing and partnerships with more than five strategic suppliers, helped reduce redundant products by roughly 40 percent and improve front-end gross margin by about 30 percent, according to the company.

“A wider range looks like a better offer, but some products were doing the same job for the customer,” Zhou said. “Each one carried its own cost in planning, stock and space.”

Cash before the customer pays

Prepaid plans are often cited as an advantage of subscription models, because customers pay in advance. Zhou sees them as an obligation as well. “A prepayment is a promise to deliver future boxes,” he said. “That has to be backed by stock, or by the ability to buy it.”

Inventory days at MollyBox fell from approximately 45 to 21 during Zhou’s supply-chain tenure, releasing cash that had been tied up in stock. He also arranged more than RMB30 million a year in supply-chain financing capacity with partners, Ju said.

From the box to the company

When Zhou became acting chief executive, he applied the same accounting to the wider business. Underperforming initiatives were wound down, proprietary-brand development was restarted, and three rounds of cost reduction cut management costs by about 60 percent and financial costs by about 30 percent while the business continued to grow, according to the company. Annual sales have reached approximately RMB480 million, according to company figures.

The figures are reported by the company, and the market around MollyBox is changing. Urban spending on pet dogs and cats in China grew 4.1 percent in 2025, down from 7.5 percent a year earlier, according to industry white-paper data. Slower growth makes the economics of each order matter more, not less.

“Cutting cost is not a strategy on its own,” Zhou said. “The point is to know what each order, each product and each group of customers actually earns, so you know which growth is worth paying for. In a subscription business, the supply chain isn’t supporting the model. It is the model.”

About the Author

Sowmiya Sri Mani is a prolific writer covering AI, Business, Technology, Markets, and Lifestyle. She loves turning complex subjects into something readers might enjoy and understand. For her, writing is about finding the interesting side of a subject and making it worth the reader’s time.